When you think of the summer of 1999, a few things likely come to mind: the impending Y2K panic, the rise of Napster, and the omnipresence of a certain buttery-smooth guitar riff accompanied by the vocals of Matchbox Twenty’s Rob Thomas. That song, “Smooth,” was the spearhead of an album that, by all reasonable expectations, should never have happened. That album was Supernatural .
It reigned on the Billboard 200 chart for 12 non-consecutive weeks and stayed on the chart for over two years. In the era of *NSYNC and Backstreet Boys, a 52-year-old Mexican-American guitarist dominated the global charts. That is unprecedented. No album this successful escapes critique. Some die-hard Santana purists argued that Supernatural was not a "real" Santana album. They claimed it was a Clive Davis marketing product—too slick, too polished, too reliant on guest stars. In their eyes, Supernatural lacked the psychedelic jamming of Abraxas or the spiritual jazz of Caravanserai . santana supernatural album
Perhaps the darkest track on the album. Everlast (of House of Pain fame) delivers a gothic, bluesy warning about demons and salvation. The call-and-response between Everlast’s gruff voice and Santana’s weeping guitar is haunting. It won a Grammy for Best Pop Collaboration with Vocals. When you think of the summer of 1999,
A gently swaying track featuring the Dave Matthews Band frontman. It’s a mellow, philosophical love song that bridges the jam-band world of Matthews with Santana’s jazz instincts. The guitar solo here is restrained but emotionally devastating. It reigned on the Billboard 200 chart for
Carlos Santana was initially hesitant. He was proud of his band and wary of becoming a hired gun on his own album. However, Davis introduced him to a young, hungry producer named Matt Serletic (known for his work with Matchbox Twenty). Serletic brought a blueprint: match Santana’s soaring, melodic leads with contemporary Latin pop, rock, and R&B.
Furthermore, the success of the album created a "template trap." In the years following Supernatural , Santana released Shaman (2002) and All That I Am (2005), which tried to replicate the formula with diminishing returns (e.g., Michelle Branch, Steven Tyler, and Chad Kroeger).
For Carlos Santana, the iconic guitarist who had burned his image into the collective consciousness at Woodstock in 1969, the 1980s and 1990s had been a period of creative wandering. While he remained a stellar live act, his studio albums had become formulaic, failing to capture the fire of his early work with Arista Records. By the late 1990s, many critics had filed Santana away as a legacy act—a “classic rock” footnote.